A response to “Yes To Yoga”

Take a Pass on Yoga
How can I support a practice that is targeting the young and the weak?
by Holly Vicente Robaina posted 06/07/2005 09:00 a.m.
This is a response to Agnieszka Tennant’s “Yes to Yoga,” which recently appeared on Christianity Today’s website. Agnieszka wrote her article in response to my piece, “The Truth About Yoga,” which appeared in Today’s Christian Woman’s March/April 2005 issue.
While I recognize Agnieszka’s right to practice yoga, I’ve got to take a pass—and I feel compelled to encourage other Christians to pass on yoga, too.
I was deeply involved in the New Age before I became a Christian. Trances, channeling spirits, and past-life regression were normal practices for me back then. So was yoga.
Like Laurette Willis, whose story is featured in “The Truth About Yoga,” I was raised in a Christian home. I accepted Jesus as a child, was baptized, attended a Christian school, and participated in Bible quizzing. When I headed off to college, I thought my faith was rock solid.
A Ouija board game in college started my journey into the New Age. It seemed so innocent at the time—a plastic pointer on top of a piece of cardboard printed with the alphabet. It seemed like Monopoly or Scrabble. Though I’d been warned about Ouija boards by church youth leaders, this didn’t look like anything that could hurt me.
It took many years and many prayers for me to let go of my New Age practices and to be healed from the pain they caused me. Until last fall, when I met Laurette Willis, I’d never met another Christian who’d come out of the New Age. (To be fair, I’ve kept pretty quiet about my experience.) Laurette told me she hadn’t met any before, either. (And she’s been extremely vocal about her experience.)
Both Laurette and I have met quite a few New Agers who’d grown up in Christian households, attended church, or even been professing believers.
Just before I wrote “The Truth About Yoga,” I was looking for a stretching routine that would offer an alternative to yoga. I’d practiced yoga for years and loved the feel of stretching and relaxing from a day’s stresses. But after I became a Christian, I sensed something spiritual about yoga that made me uneasy. (I later discovered yoga’s Hindu origins and understood why I’d felt uneasy—New Age beliefs and practices are largely derived from Hinduism.)
So when I heard about a new exercise program dubbed “Christian yoga,” I thought I’d found my alternative. And I figured TCW readers would love to learn about it, too.
I interviewed two Christian yoga instructors along with Laurette and had contacted others when I began putting the story together. As I was working on it, I felt troubled by some of the statements made by Christian yoga instructors and characteristics of their programs. At first, I ignored it, thinking I was hypersensitive and being too nitpicky because of my own New Age past. I became deeply concerned again when I discovered one of my interviewees—a Christian yoga instructor who’d been featured prominently in articles by several Christian publications—had links to a New Age website on her Christian yoga site. I prayed about it, began deeply researching more than a dozen Christian yoga programs, and prayed some more. Finally, I contacted Today’s Christian Woman editor Jane Johnson Struck. We agreed it was best to stick to a profile on Laurette Willis.
Laurette never contacted me about her PraiseMoves program, nor did she send promotional material to TCW. I didn’t even know she was working on a book for Harvest House. I found her website through a search engine, and it was my decision (with support from the TCW editors) to focus on her story.
The big differenceI’ve found that yoga practitioners—both Christians and those who are not believers—are extremely defensive of yoga. I can understand why. Stretching feels fabulous, and there’s a dearth of stretching programs out there. That was yet another reason it seemed helpful to highlight PraiseMoves, a stretching program created by a Christian, for Christians.
Agnieszka seems to believe PraiseMoves is yoga with Christian terminology thrown in. I’d correct that statement and say Laurette’s program is a Christian stretching program that seeks to reflect the physical benefits of yoga while replacing Hindu spiritualism with Christian worship.
Is there really a difference? I’ve practiced yoga with many different instructors (who all said they taught purely “physical exercise” without any yogic spiritualism), and I’ve done the PraiseMoves program myself. So I’d offer a resounding “Yes, there’s a big difference,” along with an illustration.
I have a Buddhist friend who practices ancestor worship—she goes to a temple, lights a stick of incense, and leaves food for her deceased relatives. There are Christians who light candles in remembrance of deceased relatives, or set a place at their holiday table for someone who has passed. The actions are similar, but the intent and settings are different. The Christians aren’t worshiping their deceased relatives (intent), or performing a symbolic gesture inside a Buddhist temple or in a uniquely Buddhist way (setting).
I believe Agnieszka’s personal intent in practicing yoga is good and pure. She loves Jesus, sees yoga as exercise, and likely would never be seduced into the deeper spiritualism that is inherent in all yoga. But yoga has a history, a “setting” of postures and language that pays homage to Hindu deities. While American instructors may water down that language, I think it’s safe to say most are still using it. The word namaste is still used in many yoga classes, including Agnieszka’s, and it’s a term Hindus use when paying respect to their deities. Even when used between friends, the term still really means, “I bow to the god within you.” (Agnieszka offers a different translation in her article. While the word gets translated differently depending on the source, I believe my translation, which comes from a number of Hindu websites, is closer to its true intent. It is a Sanskrit/Hindu word, and Hindus believe all living things are part of god, i.e. we are all gods. Some explain this belief as “monotheistic polytheism.”) And most instructors—including, it seems, Agnieszka’s—use traditional Sanskrit terms that have been translated into English, such as downward facing dog, corpse pose, and sun salutation. The last one, by the way, directly pays homage to the Hindu sun god—it isn’t called a “salute to the sun” for nothin’.
Minority reportEven if a Christian can get past the Hindu origins of yoga, what about those who are instructing the class? What’s their intent? On the Internet, you’ll find a jillion yoga instructors who offer definitions similar to this one found on yogabasics.com: “Yoga is … aimed at integrating mind, body and spirit, and achieving a state of enlightenment or oneness with the universe. What is normally thought of as ‘yoga’ in the West is really Hatha Yoga, one of the many paths of yoga. These different paths of yoga are simply different approaches and techniques that all lead to the same goal of unification and enlightenment.” The definition was written by the website’s founder, who has instructed yoga for 16 years.
As for American-style yoga being just exercise, the site goes on to say: “More than just stretching, asanas [yoga postures] open the energy channels, chakras and psychic centers of the body. Asanas purify and strengthen the body and control and focus the mind.”
These are not fringe views shared only by hardcore Hindu yogis. Rather, Agnieszka’s view—that the Hindu spiritualism within American yoga has largely been extracted, making it purely exercise—seems to be in the minority. Kaiser Permanente, a major healthcare provider, says this about yoga on its website: “Yoga has been practiced for thousands of years in India and is based on the idea that the mind and body are one. It is thought that yoga improves health by improving how you see the world, which calms the spirit and decreases stress.” Kaiser offers low-cost yoga classes to members, and regularly advertises this in its member newsletter.
Yoga is everywhere. Classes are taught in churches and nursing homes, through city recreation programs, and at elementary schools—both private and public. Meanwhile, numerous studies show prayer and faith have a healing effect, and that religion is good for your overall health. But you probably won’t see your local city hall renting a room for prayer meetings at the senior center any time soon.
Perhaps it has become so common that it’s now easy to overlook yoga’s origins—and its inherent Hindu spirituality—even when the Hindu and yoga communities are loudly proclaiming, “Yes, all of yoga is Hinduism. Everyone should be aware of this fact” (from an e-mail written to Laurette Willis by a staff member of the Classical Yoga Hindu Academy in New Jersey).
Agnieszka references 1 Corinthians 8 in her article to illustrate how yoga might not cause a strong Christian to stumble. But she doesn’t mention the last part of the passage, where Paul goes on to say:
“Be careful, however, that the exercise of your freedom does not become a stumbling block to the weak. For if anyone with a weak conscience sees you who have this knowledge eating in an idol’s temple, won’t he be emboldened to eat what has been sacrificed to idols? So this weak brother, for whom Christ died, is destroyed by your knowledge. When you sin against your brothers in this way and wound their weak conscience, you sin against Christ” (verses 9-12).
And I’ll admit it—I loved yoga. Perhaps I’m even a strong enough Christian now to begin a yoga class again. But my decision to say no to yoga isn’t just about me. Children are being exposed to yoga’s spiritualism at school and in after-school programs. (I remember being taken through a guided meditation as a teen at a youth recreation program, though I had no idea what it was at the time.) And I’ve read many stories about doctors who encourage the elderly, depressed patients, the mentally ill, and terminal patients to practice yoga for its mental and spiritual benefits—as if there is no better comfort available in the world than yoga.
So even if I’m strong enough, how can I support a practice that seems to be targeting the young and the weak? I take 1 Corinthians 8:13 most seriously: “Therefore, if what I eat causes my brother to fall into sin, I will never eat meat again, so that I will not cause him to fall.”
For me, giving up yoga is even easier than it would be to give up meat because there are alternatives. (There aren’t many alternatives to a good steak!) I can still stretch. I can meditate on Scripture. I can slow down, take deep breaths, relax, and thank God for the many gifts he’s given me. And I can pray that more Christians like Laurette Willis will be moved to develop alternatives to yoga.
Lastly, I’d like to address the idea that some evangelicals are engaging in fear-mongering about yoga. It’s easy to become afraid of things we don’t understand, especially practices that use a different language and come from a different culture. But fear also can be a God-given response that keeps us out of danger. As someone who was deeply involved in New Age and metaphysical practices, I can tell you from experience: There is a spiritual realm in this world. There are spiritual battles being fought. And there are frightening things from which we need to run—even if, like that Ouija board, they look benign on the surface.


6 responses to “

  1. Interesting take on Yoga… There are many, many stretching exercises for literally every joint and muscle in the body. One doesn’t have to chant mantra’s and such whilst doing them either. Stretching is rather time consuming if your rigorous w/ it. I know people who watch t.v. while they do their routines each evening. One could, obviously and of course, spend time in prayer with our Heavely Father as the exercises are being done.

  2. Thanks for posting the Christianity Today stories.

    I believe Christians love yoga because of the stretching. When you stretch, you have to slow down, take your time, let your muscles and brain relax. Yoga is an organized stretching routine with Hindu spirituality.

    It’s a difficult subject because yoga is the most visible stretching program out there (I couldn’t name any others that would be so available), and stretching is good for the body. I believe the middle ground will be found when Christians who are gifted in exercise step up, create, and make available stretching programs that don’t incorporate Hindu spirituality. I hope the discussion created by the CT stories will get some thinking about this.

    Thanks for providing a forum for thoughts here, and for your own willingness to feel out the subject.

    Holly Vicente Robaina

  3. Dave McDowell

    Holly, what an honor! I did a double-take on your name until I realized that you were the one who wrote the response article in Christianity Today. I am indeed honored to have you on my blog(Awww shucks). Thanks for reading and providing additonal comments. So Holly, what do you say? Since you are so passionate about the subject, why not develop a Christian stretching program? Sounds like a great idea.

    Love and peace,

    Dave M.

  4. Boy, if I had any talent/training in exercise, you bet I would! But I have to leave that up to those like Laurette Willis, who are actually gifted in that area. If I tried to create a stretching program, people probably would throw out their backs.

    I’m glad you posted both Agnieszka’s story and mine. I think it’s so important for Christians to share their experiences, stories, and perspectives–especially on subjects where we don’t all agree. I’ve so often seen God use stories to give others comfort and clarity. I’ve even heard people say that a story they read was an answer to prayer. God definitely has used others’ stories to speak to me.

    And if we approach that by saying, “This is my experience. Here are my conclusions, based on what I’ve read in the Bible. I’ve prayed about it, and this is what God put on my heart. I want to share it with you because he may be speaking to your heart,” others are more apt to think about that perspective.

    I think the church is too often seen as demanding, “Do this” and “Don’t do this.” It would be so great if everyone could say, “Here’s my experience. Tell me yours. We may not agree, but at least we can try to understand why the other feels this way.” God must have given us diverse experiences for a reason, so it seems we should both share and listen (exactly what you’re doing with your blog!).


  5. I agree with you Holly. Although I am reformed, I still listen to those who aren’t. Although I am charismatic, I still listen to those who aren’t. And even though I am Baptist, I still listen to those who baptize infants. The old saying is “even a broke clock is right twice a day.” I may not agree with everything I hear, but that does not make any less valid.

    Dave M.

  6. Swami Jnaneshvara Bharati (Swamiji, Swami J)

    Would one say that people drinking wine are necessarily practicing the Christian rite of communion? Would one say that people eating bread with a meal are practicing the Christian rite of communion? Of course not.

    If one does physical postures outside of its context as a 100% spiritual practice, you cannot call it Yoga, any more than you can call merely drinking wine and eating bread Christian communion.

    Here is a brief video entitled
    “Can a Christian Practice Yoga?”

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s